We ordered their apple almond tart and chocolate jasmine bar. It was certainly fun watching both being prepared while jamming to great soul tunes.My girlfriend still daydreams over their muscavado ice cream that came with her chocolate jasmine bar, while I recall the constant balance between almond and apple as texture and temperature contrasted - almond meal against apple slices, warm tart against chilled diced apples.
V-Day brought us to an empty restaurant with staff bustling about with preparations. I misunderstood they were only doing a fixed price menu (makes sense for such a crazy day) as we sat down. Noah overheard us debating because we had wanted to sample their savory menu. He kindly excused us for another day and another attempt, but not before sharing champagne sorbet with us. Sugarmill - leaving impressive impressions. Go there.
Good thing I listen to and take my own advice. Our third visit placed us directly before Denver Restaurant Week's bustling madness and more fixed price menus. I'm not against fixed price menus, but when there are many things to explore on Sugarmill's regular menu, I want that experience. However, fixed menus are great for managing budgets and restaurants can focus on select items rather than two separate menus.
This evening's focus was dinner. We've done sweets, a tease, now savory awaited.
We took much time browsing the menu. We discovered the short rib tortellini was through and instead they featured a special with salmon, house made fettuccine, and parmesan mushroom sauce. The foie gras torchon had also been eliminated. Restaurant Week was a'comin' and they were starting a new menu March 1. We decided to begin with the hummus.
This $4 plate featured red and golden beet hummus topped with pistachios and beet cubes and accompanied by a lightly oil drizzled baguette. The hummus was substantive, yet light. The beet flavor was prevalent not dominant. The golden beet hummus was perhaps a touch sweeter. With these generous helpings, be prepared to generously top your bread and use your silverware as backup.
We knew the main dish ending our meal, but we wanted a middle item. We couldn't agree, so eventually we asked our server. She suggested the roasted mushroom toast. It starts with a thick slice of earthy dark bread, topped with roasted mushrooms with arugula, julienned radish, and parmesan. Truffle is the first scent that arises. The parmesan was lightly melted, the bread easily cut and divided. It was a delicious mushroom treat.
Our finishing bite was crispy salmon atop their house made fettuccine, parmesan mushroom sauce and lemony 'chokes. I marveled at the salmon's richness and hunted down those 'chokes (arti- or sun-, I couldn't tell). Even with two splitting, we still had leftovers.
And... and... Noah tempted us once more with lemon and chocolate mocha macarons. These were not the airy macarons I know in France, but macarons with some heft. So good!
Their spring menu began March 1 and I will return. From my three visits, I have some overall impressions to share. 1. With generous portions and high quality food, Sugarmill could and perhaps should raise their prices $1-2. I never say this, but I am today. 2. It's rare to see a chef leave his kitchen, but Noah frequently does to encourage people to try his savory or sweet foods, find the restroom, and deliver a menu item. His open personality is found within his staff also. 3. He's made me into someone who wants to be a regular. That is extraordinary, but I'm a willing participant. With avidly writing reviews on Yelp, I always strive to find new places and rarely return to old ones. A few places make the cut, but I'm always drawn to the next bright thing. It seems that Sugarmill will continue burning bright on my horizon.
2461 Larimer St
Denver, CO 80205